Friday, January 4, 2013

Mark Lynas Recants On GM Agriculture

Some things never change.  However, many things do.  Sometimes, even the strongest of opinions can reverse direction.  Consider opposition to genetically-modified ("GM") crops and livestock.  Mark Lynas has long been one of the most eloquent and prominent opponents of GM agriculture.  In fact, he was a primary architect of widespread anti-GM public opinion in Europe.  On January 3, 2012, during an address at the 2013 Oxford Farming Conference, Lynas recounted how he achieved this:
When I first heard about Monsanto’s GM soya I knew exactly what I thought. Here was a big American corporation with a nasty track record, putting something new and experimental into our food without telling us. Mixing genes between species seemed to be about as unnatural as you can get – here was humankind acquiring too much technological power; something was bound to go horribly wrong. These genes would spread like some kind of living pollution. It was the stuff of nightmares.

These fears spread like wildfire, and within a few years GM was essentially banned in Europe, and our worries were exported by NGOs like Greenpeace and Friends of the Earth to Africa, India and the rest of Asia, where GM is still banned today. This was the most successful campaign I have ever been involved with.
 Remarkably, Lynas then apologized for this very success, and publicly embraced GM agriculture, in the process portraying vilifying anti-GM environmentalists:
For the record, here and upfront, I apologise for having spent several years ripping up GM crops. I am also sorry that I helped to start the anti-GM movement back in the mid 1990s, and that I thereby assisted in demonising an important technological option which can be used to benefit the environment...
This was also explicitly an anti-science movement. We employed a lot of imagery about scientists in their labs cackling demonically as they tinkered with the very building blocks of life. Hence the Frankenstein food tag – this absolutely was about deep-seated fears of scientific powers being used secretly for unnatural ends. What we didn’t realise at the time was that the real Frankenstein’s monster was not GM technology, but our reaction against it.
Lynas is now treading a path of conversion blazed before him by the "Skeptical Environmentalist," Bjorn Lomborg, a man whose face Lynas once festooned with a cream pie.  Like Lomborg, Lynas will surely be demonized by many of his previous comrades as an apostate guilty of ideological treason.

I have long been fascinated by attitudes towards GM agriculture.  In "Intellectual Property as the Third Dimension of GMO Regulation" (available free here), I analyzed the ironic tension between opposition to GM agriculture and opposition to patents claiming GM crops and livestock.  More recently, in "Planted Obsolescence:  Synagriculture and the Law" (available free here), I suggested that "synagriculture" (that is, agriculture based on a framework of open synthetic biology) is likely to transform agriculture by democratizing access to powerful biotechnological methods and materials capable of engineering miraculous new varieties of agricultural organisms and techniques.

As opponents and proponents battle for the soul of agricultural progress, and GM agriculture continues its worldwide march towards technological dominance, food and other products from farming remain as important as ever.  As Milton had Eve exhort in Book IX of Paradise Lost, "Adam, well may we labour, still to dress/ This garden, still to tend plant, herb, and flower."


  1. As you choose from the yachting shirts that are available in the market, there are different considerations that should be taken into account. The style and the design, including the color will prove to be important. The same thing is true in the case of material and brand name. With such, some of the possibilities recommended in the Best Polo Shirt will be identified below.

  2. some of the possibilities recommended in the Best Polo Shirt will be identified below.
    Gclub มือถือ

  3. Progress of agricultural techniques has progressively increased agricultural productivity. Marvelous and fairly great farms employ workers to undertake the range of jobs relating to cultivation of crops and care of farm animals.vladimir vrbaski republika

  4. Excellent article. Very interesting to read. I really love to read such a nice article. Thanks! keep rocking.
    Sindh irrigated Agriculture

  5. Antes de montar uma granja é preciso saber tudo que é necessário para fazer esse negócio dar certo. Além do planejamento, é necessário conhecer minuciosamente toda a operação e estrutura do segmento.
    montar uma granja

  6. It is very clear that agriculture investment, especially investing in agricultural land, displays the characteristics of growth, income, a positive correlation with inflation, is easy to value, and has a clear and evident track record to analyse, and as such agriculture investment ticks all of the relevant boxes to potentially become the ideal asset class for investors today.Basmati rice Price

  7. Spotters in the agriculture calling fall into different classes such staffing, held hunt, perpetual arrangement, and transitory situation. Basmati Rice Price

  8. Agriculture is an alternative investment class which is currently gaining traction on account of traditionally strong performance and positive returns to investors, especially in comparison with some other traditional assets. Nevertheless, it is important to think about the impact of agricultural investments in developing countries especially and to consider how to use those investments so as to contribute to sustainable development. Recently, the International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED), an independent non-profit research institute, published an article exploring the purchase of land by agricultural investment funds in developing countries and the actions that might be taken to promote investments... agriculture algerie

  9. Agriculture has played a key role in the development of human civilization. Agriculture is important for numerous reasons, the most central of which is that we all need to eat. Agriculture refers to the production of foodstuff and fiber and additional goods through farming and forestry. Before the arrival of Industrial upheaval, the vast bulk of the human population labored in agriculture. Enlargement of Deutz Fahr Parts Catalog techniques has gradually increased agricultural yield.

  10. It is not common knowledge as to when the first English Garden Room was built at the bottom of an English garden. It might have been in the late 18th century that architect William Kent's potting shed spurred the interest in an outside retreat. Or perhaps it was the erection of 2.1 million Anderson World War 2 air raid shelters late in 1938? The Garden Room has it's place alongside mother nature herself - an abiding existence with so many forms and functions. vegetable seedlings online Australia