Wednesday, September 18, 2013

The State War Against Patent Trolls

Increasingly, states within the United States have been taking up cudgels against what are variously known as non-practicing entities ("NPEs"), patent assertion entities ("PAE"), and patent trolls.  The anti-patent troll bandwagon has now rolled into the Great Plains.  The attorney general of Nebraska, Republican Jon Bruning has now thrown down the gauntlet, as reported in an article entitled "Nebraska’s attorney general has declared war on patent trolls," published on September 12, 2013, in the Washington Post.  As in other states, one of the legal grounds for opposing patent troll activities in Nebraska is the state unfair competition law.  As state action against patent trolls gather speed, fewer and fewer bridges may remain under which trolls may hide.

Tuesday, September 17, 2013

Patently Funny Seeds Of Discord

The Daily Show has shown a laudable fascination with patent law over the past year.  Its latest foray into patent doctrine involves a report on the patenting of genetically-engineered seeds, entitled "Monsanto & Seed Patent Laws."  Thanks to biotechnology patent law genius Kevin Noonan, one of the founding Patent Docs, for directing me to this story.

Monday, September 16, 2013

Dear Life

Loss of biodiversity is one of the great crises facing humanity and the earth it inhabits.  Unlike greenhouse gas accumulation, diminution of the ozone layer, and most forms of pollution, loss of biodiversity is irreversible.  Even if the most optimistic hopes for deextinction are one day realized, and individual species are indeed revived, living communities and ecosystems are far too complex ever to be faithfully reconstituted.  British newsmagazine The Economist includes an in-depth special report on biodiversity in its September 14th-20th, 2013, issue, entitled "Hang on - How economic growth will help prevent extinctions."  The report ends with the following bold admonition:
Many in the environmental movement regard economic growth and technological progress as enemies of biodiversity. Actually, they are its friends. Only through more of both can man hope to go on enjoying the company of the 8.7m or so other species with which he was born to share this planet.
Trust The Economist to inject its relentlessly commonsensical, yet simultaneously iconoclastic, perspective into this vital issue.  The cause of biodiversity preservation is so important that all views should be welcomed.

Friday, September 13, 2013

One Patent To Rule Them All

After years of negotiations, false dawns, and frustratingly-high patent prosecution costs, Europe is about receive both a unitary patent and a unified patent court.  The United Kingdom branch of the Association Internationale pour la Protection de la Propriété Intellectuelle ("AIPPI") has published a series of extremely useful slide presentations explaining various aspects of these patent reforms.  Although the full implications of the unitary patent and unified patent court will not be known for years, these AIPPI presentations are highly informative.

Thursday, September 12, 2013

Deextinction In Kansas

Deextinction has been in the news in Lawrence, Kansas recently.  On August 21, 2013, the University of Kansas website featured an article entitled "Professor Examining Potential Laws To Regulate De-Extinction," which discussed my involvement with the legal issues surrounding efforts to revive extinct species.  Then, on September 7, 2013, the Lawrence Journal-World published an article entitled "Back from oblivion: The discussion around bringing extinct species back to life," and an accompanying September 9, 2013, blogpost entitled "Taking a Neanderthal out to coffee," for both of which I had the pleasure of being interviewed by reporter Ben Unglesbee.
Professor examining potential laws to regulate de-extinction - See more at: http://news.ku.edu/2013/08/21/professor-taking-lead-potential-laws-de-extinction#sthash.M8QApL54.dpuf
Professor examining potential laws to regulate de-extinction - See more at: http://news.ku.edu/2013/08/21/professor-taking-lead-potential-laws-de-extinction#sthash.M8QApL54.dpuf
Professor examining potential laws to regulate de-extinction - See more at: http://news.ku.edu/2013/08/21/professor-taking-lead-potential-laws-de-extinction#sthash.M8QApL54.dpabout my involvement with deextinction

Competition On Noncompetes

In law school intellectual property classes, a comparison is commonly made between the unenforcability of noncompetition agreements in California and their enforceability in Massachusetts.  These two states have traditionally dominated in high technology and biotechnology industries in the United States.  Right Coast Massachusetts now appears to be tipping towards the Californian Left Coast mentality that noncompetes hinder worker mobility, thereby hampering entrepreneurship.  On September 10, 2013, Massachusetts Secretary of Housing and Economic Development, Gregory Bialecki, testified at hearings held by the Massachusetts Legislature's Joint Committee on Labor and Workforce Development that Massachusetts should both end the enforcement of noncompetition agreements and adopt the Uniform Trade Secrets Act.  Here is an excerpt from his testimony:
We want innovative businesses. A priority of this Administration has been to support and enhance the innovation economy. Massachusetts has long had a vibrant and leading edge in research and the innovative community. Many of the fundamental technological advances like the Internet economy and digital media had beginnings in Massachusetts in the past couple of decades. However, we could do more. We need more start-ups, especially in the technology and bio-tech sectors. Start-ups are good; they create jobs, push innovation to new heights, and retain talent. Many of our current employers, larger and small, report they are unable to attract lateral or advanced talent due to our current laws limiting the mobility of our workforce... 
The Uniform Trade Secret Act (UTSA) has been adopted in 47 other states and the District of Columbia. The UTSA and other tools protect an employer’s trade secrets and proprietary  information, which is fundamentally important. Patents, confidentiality agreements, and trade secrets are more than sufficient to protect legitimate company interests against former employees. Even without non-compete agreements, companies still have a disproportionate ability to litigate against the individual...
For these reasons, we support outright elimination of enforceability of non-comp[eti]tive agreements in Massachusetts combined with adoption of the Uniform Trade Secrets Act.
Though many businesses will have misgivings about these reforms, influential members of the Massachusetts Bar support them.  Perhaps this legal innovation will finally provide the technological edge necessary to solve Massachusetts' most intractable challenge:  how to pahk yah cah in Hahvahd Yahd.

Wednesday, September 11, 2013

How Bout Them Apples?

The magazine Fast Company has compiled a fascinating history of design at Apple Inc..  As the originator, or sometimes perfecter, of many iconic designs in both software and hardware, Apple has become increasingly reliant on good design - not to mention design patent protection - to distinguish itself from copycat or sloppycat competitors.  If, as Goethe wrote, "Architecture is frozen music," Apple design, at its best, can reach the level of defrosted jazz.

Tuesday, September 10, 2013

Put Upon By Putin

President Barack Obama appears to have fallen victim to the diplomatic equivalent of an epaulet mate.  Hemmed in, on one side, by Secretary of State John Kerry's fanciful suggestion that Syria surrender its stockpile of chemical weapons to the international community, and, on the other side, by his erstwhile ally David Cameron's ill-fated decision to seek Parliamentary approval for military action to punish Syria for allegedly using chemical weapons against its own civilians,  Obama has been pushed to the edge of policy paralysis by Congress and public opinion.  Clichéed though it may be, Russian President Vladimir Putin appears to have proven himself a master at diplomatic chess by immediately accepting Kerry's offhand offer.  Efforts to build support for military strikes against Syria have struck out - at least for now.

Monday, September 9, 2013

Pip Pip, EPIP!

For almost a decade, EPIP ("European Policy for Intellectual Property") Association has been the leading scholarly organization for European intellectual property law.  As its website explains, "EPIP is an international, independent, interdisciplinary, non-profit association of researchers, that grew out of a network financed by the European Commission from 2003 to 2005."  On September 5th and 6th, 2013, the 8th Annual Conference of the EPIP Association was held in Paris, graciously hosted by Telecom ParisTech.  I was honored to deliver a keynote address on the unpatentability of inventions based on structures of, and processes carried out by, human beings.  The excellent full program is available here.  The conference was very well attended by an impressive and friendly array of scholars, attorneys, and policymakers from across Europe and beyond.  This year's EPIP conference may be over, but "We'll always have Paris."

Wednesday, September 4, 2013

Microsoft's Phoney Patents

After a brief and inelegant pas de deux, Microsoft Corporation has decided to dance solo by spending $US 7.17 billion for Nokia Corporation's mobile phone business and intellectual property.  In its latest effort to become a contender in mobile phones, Microsoft announced on September 3, 2013, that it would acquire both Nokia's "devices and services business" ($US 4.99 billion) and a "broad intellectual property license" ($US 2.17 billion).  Naturally, patents are at the heart of this massive bet.  Microsoft will acquire 8,500 design patents and a license to roughly 30,000 utility patents and patent applications.  Whatever its future as a purveyor of services and devices, Microsoft has now solidified its status as one of the premier patent hegemons.