Tuesday, January 14, 2014

Network Neutrality Nixed

Today (January 14, 2014), the highly-influential United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia rejected Federal Communications Commission ("FCC") rules aimed at ensuring network neutrality.  With two federal courts having rejected the FCC's network neutrality rules, it will likely not be long before the United States Supreme Court decides this issue.

Dan Goor's Nine-Nine Shine-Time

Congratulations to Executive Producer, Creator, and Writer Dan Goor on his Golden Globe Award for Brooklyn Nine-Nine!  It's been a long time since we both lived in Eliot House - he as a student and I as the Biology Tutor - and ate together in the Dining Hall.  He was brilliantly funny then, and it's been fun watching him rise in comedy from strength to strength.

Monday, January 6, 2014

Law Which Alters When It Alteration Finds

The New York Times published a wonderfully-detailed article on January 5, 2014, chronicling how the Big Island, Hawai'i, arrived at a new ban on genetically-modified organisms ("GMOs").  Entitled "A Lonely Quest for Facts on Genetically Modified Crops," the article follows the dogged pursuit of the science of GMOs by Gregor Illagan, a member of the Hawai'i County Council, in advance of a proposed GMO ban.  The ban, in Bill 113, was passed by the Council and signed into law by Mayor William P. Kenoi on December 4, 2013.
In 2007, I published article, "Intellectual Property as the Third Dimension of GMO Regulation," which discusses the issues surrounding GMO regulation.  Here is the abstract:
In the past, opposition to GMOs and GM crops has tended to focus on alleged dangers to human health and environmental safety. The United States, Canada, and Europe have all established regulatory frameworks whose stated aims are to ensure that GMOs and GM crops do not harm the health of their citizens or threaten the well-being of their environments. However, these jurisdictions have set up regulatory hurdles of significantly different heights. North American neighbors, the United States and Canada, have tended to regulate GMOs and GM crops with a relatively light touch that tends to ease approval for field-testing and commercial marketing. By contrast, Europe has applied much stricter regulatory standards, with the result that few GM crops have been field-tested or GM foods allowed onto the market there. A large and growing body of scientific studies into the human health and environmental safety of GMOs and GM crops has failed to find significant justification for the extreme precautionary approach adopted by Europe. Furthermore, a WTO panel decision forcefully critical of the European regulatory regime for GMOs and GM crops was recently accepted by Europe, and may herald the adoption of a new regulatory regime more accepting of GMOs and GM crops.

As prospects have faded that scientific evidence will demonstrate that GMOs and GM crops pose unique threats to human health and environmental safety, a third locus of anxieties has been growing in significance: patent monopolies over new and useful GM crops. Concerns about monopoly control of GM crops are the obverse of concerns about human health and environmental safety. Where the latter rationales counsel against the easy and widespread adoption of GM crops, the former rationale would operate to ensure such easy and widespread adoption. Both the United States and Europe offer patent protection for GM plants and animals, making regulation against patent monopolies in GM crops difficult. However, Canada does not allow the patenting of GM plants and animals, thus avoiding patent monopolies in GM crops per se. Ironically, just as Europe might look to Canada for a new method of regulating GMOs and GM crops, Canada may be undergoing a transition toward allowing such inventions to be patented.

Of the three loci of regulation of GMOs and GM crops, the patent system maintains the most integrity. The scientific justifications for strictly limiting GMOs and GM crops due to concerns over human health and environmental safety have yet to materialize to any significant degree. In fact, there is so little scientific evidence of unique risks of GMOs and GM crops that even invocation of a conservative precautionary principle may be unjustified. Regardless of how regulation of GMOs and GM crops changes in Canada and Europe in the future, it is likely that concerns over monopoly control will grow in significance as a rationale for regulation, while the rationales of human health and environmental safety will continue to fade in the absence of a reversal of the current trend of scientific evidence.
The issues involved in the Hawai'i debate recur predictably in almost debates over GMOs.  One of these is the initial emphasis on health and environmental safety followed by the emergence of concerns about monopolies and patents.  Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose.

Tuesday, December 31, 2013

For Auld Lang Syne!

There is no better way to ring in the New Year than to sing Robert Burns' Scots-language poem, Auld Lang Syne.  Here, in all its ebullient and impenetrable glory, is the entire poem:
Should auld acquaintance be forgot,
And never brought to mind?
Should auld acquaintance be forgot,
And auld lang syne!

Chorus.- For auld lang syne, my dear,
For auld lang syne.
We'll tak a cup o' kindness yet,
For auld lang syne.

And surely ye'll be your pint stowp!
And surely I'll be mine!
And we'll tak a cup o'kindness yet,
For auld lang syne.
For auld, &c.

We twa hae run about the braes,
And pou'd the gowans fine;
But we've wander'd mony a weary fit,
Sin' auld lang syne.
For auld, &c.

We twa hae paidl'd in the burn,
Frae morning sun till dine;
But seas between us braid hae roar'd
Sin' auld lang syne.
For auld, &c.

And there's a hand, my trusty fere!
And gie's a hand o' thine!
And we'll tak a right gude-willie waught,
For auld lang syne.
For auld, &c.
Happy New Year!

Internet Architects

The December 31, 2013, edition of the New York Times, includes a fascinating interview with two of the original architects of the technical rules that allow the internet to function.  In the article, entitled Viewing Where the Internet Goes, Vinton Cerf and Robert Kahn discuss both how they designed rules to allow the internet to flourish and impingements on those rules that may threaten the future of internet freedom.

Monday, December 30, 2013

Robot Menagerie

Robots are on the rise.  Skynet is not yet self-aware, but the fact that even Google and Amazon have now decided to place big bets on them reflects the new robotic Zeitgeist.  Interestingly, rather than start entirely from scratch, the designs of many robots are being drawn directly from biology.  Boston Dynamics - a recent Google acquisition - exemplifies this trend.  Its robots include BigDog, LittleDog, Cheetah, and SandFlea.  One of the newest members of Boston Dynamics' mechanized menagerie is WildCat, featured in this video:  
Billions of years of evolution produced extant wild cats - superb runners, jumpers, climbers, and hunters.  Designers of robots are wise to draw upon the fruits of one of the most profoundly powerful forces ever discovered:  Charles Darwin's natural selection.  Perhaps designers will soon expand their efforts beyond the mere products of natural selection, and try to use natural selection itself to design new robots.  The writing of On the Origin of Robots by Means of Natural Selection has begun.

Sunday, December 29, 2013

Copyrights And Copywrongs

The National Public Radio ("NPR") program, On The Media, rebroadcast one of its best 2013 episodes on December 29, 2013.  On The Media describes this episode, entitled "The Past, Present, and Future of Ownership," as follows:
A special hour, originally aired in March, on our changing understanding of ownership and how it is affected by the law. An author and professor who encourages creative writing through plagiarism, 3D printing, fan fiction & fair use, and the strange tale of who owns "The Happy Birthday Song."

Here is a podcast of the episode.
After listening to it, you may never again blithely click "Copy" on your computer.

Friday, December 27, 2013

The Curious Incident Of The Copyright

On Valentine's Day, 2014, Leslie S. Klinger filed, not a love letter, but a lawsuit in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Illinois, seeking declaratory judgment
establishing that the public is entitled to copy the expression embodied in [many of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's published stories chronicling the adventures of the inimitable Sherlock Holmes].
Specifically, in his motion for summary judgment, Klinger sought
a judicial determination that the [pre-1923] Sherlock Holmes [stories' expressive elements] are free for public use because the stories in which the elements were first introduced have entered the public domain.
The Conan Doyle Estate, Ltd., ("Estate") owners of the copyrights in Sherlock Holmes, opposed this position, arguing, instead, that
because Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson were continually developed throughout the entire Canon [of Sherlock Holmes stories], the copyright protecting the [post-1923 stories] should extend to the Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson characters and story elements pertaining to those characters.
In resolving the dispute, Court granted summary judgment to Klinger with respect to pre-1923 expressive elements, but allowed the Estate to maintain its copyright control over later-published expressive elements.  Of course, the Estate's victory comes with a time limit because copyright protection lasts for "limited Times" that will continue to expire as the years pass.

Sherlock Holmes has now lifted one foot out of copyright, and will soon be standing squarely within the public domain.  It has taken much effort by Klinger to achieve this partial victory through the courts.  As Sherlock Holmes himself said in The Missing Three-Quarter,
There is so much red tape in these matters. However, I have no doubt that with a little delicacy and finesse the end may be attained.
Even without delicacy or finesse, time will soon see Sherlock Holmes entirely within the public domain.

Thursday, December 26, 2013

Doctor Who Meets John Rawls

For the past half century, Doctor Who has been righting wrongs (or, at least, trying to do so) across endless expanses of space and time.  Regardless of which incarnations of the Doctor are your favorites - Jon Pertwee and Tom Baker are mine - the television series has entertained generations with more than just adventures, aliens, and acumen.  Doctor Who stories routinely rely on philosophical issues, from the logical to the metaphysical, as central drivers of the narrative.  The 50th Anniversary special, entitled The Day of the the Doctor, does this especially well.  Not only does it explore a variation of the Trolley Problem, more impressively, it imposes John Rawls' Original Position on two warring sides (that is, humans versus zygons) to force a peaceful resolution to their dispute.  As superb science fiction as it has ever been, Happy Anniversary, Doctor Who!

Wednesday, December 18, 2013

The Catastrophocene

The December 23 & 30, 2013, issue of The New Yorker has the second in a series of articles about extinction by Elizabeth Kolbert.  This article discusses the phonomenon of mass extinctions, including the current anthropogenic mass extinction event.  One of the most fascinating ideas Kolbert explores is what kind of fossil record our own civilization will leave behind for whatever posterity follows us.