Tuesday, October 22, 2013

Goodbye To Law Reviews?

A number of authors have recently questioned the influence and relevance of law reviews, including, rather prominently, Adam Liptak in the New York Times on October 21, 2013.  Liptak's article, entitled The Lackluster Reviews That Lawyers Love to Hate, humorously cites a 1936 Virginia Law Review article for support.  The article, by Fred Rodell of Yale Law School, is called Goodbye To Law Reviews.  Here is its abstract:
It is doubtless of no concern to anyone that this is probably my last law review article. As a matter of fact, this makes one more article than I had originally planned to write. It was something in the nature of a New Year's resolution. Yet the request to do a piece about law reviews seemed a golden opportunity to make my future absence from the "Leading Articles, Authors" lists a bit more pointed than would the business of merely sitting in a comer, sucking my thumb, and muttering Boo. Keeping well in line with two traditions—a course which lawyers will readily understand—I decided to break the resolution and not wait for opportunity's second knock. This, then, is by way of explaining why I do not care to contribute further to the qualitatively moribund while quantitatively mushroom-like literature of the law.

There are two things wrong with almost all legal writing. One is its style. The other is its content. That, I think, about covers the ground. And though it is in the law reviews that the most highly regarded legal literature—and I by no means except those fancy rationalizations of legal action called judicial opinions—is regularly embalmed, it is in the law reviews that a pennyworth of content is most frequently concealed beneath a pound of so-called style. The average law review writer is peculiarly able to say nothing with an air of great importance. When I Used to read law reviews, I used constantly to be reminded of an elephant trying to swat a fly.
One might ask an obvious, and logically-challenging, question prompted by the article itself:  should one bother reading it since it was published in a law review?

Friday, October 18, 2013

ET EU EH?

On October 18, 2013, Canada and the European Union signed an agreement-in-principle to free trade between their two markets.  Although the legal text has yet to be finalized (or published), one controversial aspect of the negotiations has been harmonization of Canadian patent law with that of the European Union.  It is likely that this will benefit brand pharmaceutical firms at the expense of generic drug companies, and lead to higher prices for prescription drugs claimed in valid and enforceable patents.

Thursday, October 17, 2013

Toronto's Cultural Moment

In the fall of 2013, two of the most popular strands of youth culture - hip hop and basketball - neatly knitted themselves together in Toronto, Canada.  This huge city perched on the north shore of Lake Ontario is having a rare moment of global influence.  Its source are two dominantly-talented young Torontonians:  (1) Aubrey "Drake" Graham, the current king of the music charts, and (2) Andrew Christian Wiggins, the Kansas Jayhawk consensus top freshman men's basketball player in the NCAA.  Drake bestrides hip hop with his new album "Nothing Was The Same,"  while Wiggins inspires best-since-LeBron and NBA-#1-draft-pick accolades.  Bask in your glorious moment, Toronto.

Tuesday, October 15, 2013

Standards And Patents

The United States National Academies' STEP (Board on Science, Technology, and Economic Policy) Board today (October 15, 2013) published a new report entitled Patent Challenges for Standard-Setting in the Global Economy.  The report, as summarized in an email announcing its publication, has four parts:
(1) A survey of a dozen key SSOs in the ICT arena to ascertain how their IPR policies have evolved;
(2) Recommendations to SSOs and the USG re the thorny issues of FRAND interpretation, terms of SEPs disclosures, transfer of FRAND obligations with patent ownership, transparency of patent ownership, and the availability of injunctive relief on SEPs with FRAND obligations;
(3) Examination of standards and IP policy development in China, India, and Brazil; and
(4) Discussion of the relevance to the USPTO of the European Patent Office’s information sharing arrangements with the IEEE, ITU, and ETSI.
In 2012, Linda Kahl and I were commissioned by the National Academies to write a report entitled Synthetic Biology and Intellectual Property as part of the process leading to Patent Challenges for Standard-Setting in the Global Economy, and our report will soon be published in The Santa Clara Computer & High Technology Law Journal.

Monday, October 14, 2013

Innovation Rights And The Innovation Wetlands

Professor Eric von Hippel (MIT Sloan School of Management) and I have now posted on SSRN a draft of our new article, entitled "Protecting the Right to Innovate: Our 'Innovation Wetlands'."  Our article is free to download from SSRN.  Here is the abstract:
Individual citizens have been found to be a major source of new product and service innovations of value both to themselves, and to the economy at large. These individuals operate in a little-understood legal environment that we call the innovation wetlands. We show via a review of fundamental rights guaranteed in the US Constitution and elsewhere that individuals in the US participating in the innovation wetlands have strong legal protections with respect to both their freedom to innovate and their right to diffuse information about their innovations to others. However, we also show that legislation and regulation — often promulgated without awareness of consumer innovation as a valuable resource — can, in practice, significantly interfere with individuals’ exercise of their fundamental freedom to innovate. This interference can cost society dearly.

We offer three approaches to protecting the valuable resource of innovation by individuals from excessive negative impacts caused by legislation and regulation. First, we propose enhancing general awareness of the issue by framing the concept of individual innovation rights as an "innovation wetlands" that must be protected. Second, we describe the legislative and regulatory frameworks and practices that demark today’s innovation wetlands, as experienced by individual and collaborating innovators. Third, we suggest improvements that can strengthen protection of the innovation wetlands, including heightening awareness of the issue in existing, mandated cost-benefit analyses that are already applied, although imperfectly, to regulation in the US.
I have had the great fortune of being a Visiting Scholar at the MIT Sloan School of Management for the past two years, and owe Eric von Hippel a debt of gratitude for being such a wonderful host and colleague.  He and I will further refine our new article on the "Innovation Wetlands" over the coming months.

Friday, October 11, 2013

The Unpatentable Human

The Hastings Center Report just published an article I wrote entitled The Unpatentable Human Being.  Here is the abstract:
On June 13, 2013, the Supreme Court placed its imprimatur on a principle that has been gathering force within patent law for several decades: human beings constitute unpatentable subject matter. In Association for Molecular Pathology v. Myriad Genetics, Inc., the court answered the question it had posed itself — “Are human genes patentable?” — decisively in the negative. Synthetic DNA sequences, designed by humans, were excluded from this prohibition, but the invalidation of patents claiming human genes wiped out vast amounts of private investment and was a body blow to the biotechnology industry. Nevertheless, this legal result was predictable, given a careful reading of the entrails of judicial decisions, congressional bills, executive branch pronouncements, and decisions in other countries about patents claiming human-related inventions, all of which have echoed the spirit of the Thirteenth Amendment by proscribing property rights — including intellectual property rights — in human beings. To understand how patent law has evolved toward this result, one may trace the legal treatment of patents claiming human embryonic stem cells, chemical products of human physiology, human thought, and now, human genes. Woven together, these strands of evidence led inexorably toward the ultimate rejection of human gene patents by the Supreme Court, and placed a decisive judicial exclamation mark on the unpatentability of human beings and human bodily structures and functions.
I'm working on a longer treatment of this topic as well.

Thursday, October 10, 2013

Dear Alice Munro

A week ago, I finished reading Dear Life, a book of short stories Alice Munro announced would be her last.  I raced through the book in advance of the awarding of this year's Nobel Prize in Literature, just in case the deserving Munro finally won.  Mirabile dictu, Alice Munro is the recipient of the 2013 Nobel Prize in Literature.  In the book, Munro promises that her final set of stories are her most autobiographical, though she has long mined seams from her life, especially her youth in southwestern Ontario, to enrich her magnificent literary oeuvre.  Congratulations, Alice Munro, on your Nobel Prize!  Prepare yourself for Too Much Happiness.

Tuesday, October 8, 2013

Nesting Instinct

Hardware is the new software, thanks to 3-D printing, the makers' community, and even an incipient open source hardware movement.  This bodes well for better, more elegant, hardware design.  Close on the heels of reinventing the thermostat, Nest, one of Silicon Valley's most innovative hardware companies, has released a reimagined smoke and carbon monoxide alarm, named "Protect."  As the company explains, "We take the unloved products in your home and make simple, beautiful, thoughtful things."  It's no coincidence that both of Nest's products evoke iPod, iPhones, and iPads in their simply-elegant designs, because several Nest founders are Apple alumni.  With its new Protect, Nest must be hoping that where there's smoke, there's profit.

Saturday, October 5, 2013

Big Ideas In Big Sky

Exploring A Snowy Mountainside Atop Jester
The Law & Economics Center ("LEC") at George Mason University School of Law and the Property and Environment Research Center ("PERC") are cosponsors of the LEC-PERC Workshop on Environmental Economics for Law Professors, an intensive bootcamp in law and economics for environmental law scholars, from October 2 to 6, 2013.  Organized by Terry Anderson (PERC) and Henry Butler (LEC and George Mason University School of Law), the diverse lectures include "The Scientific Method and the Economic Analysis of Law," "Environmental Markets," "Empirical Methods in Economics and Law," and "Common Law vs. Regulation," and "Natural Resource Economics."  An additional attraction is the location, in Big Sky, Montana, which is perched in spectacular mountains just west of Yellowstone National Park.  I was fortunate enough to be accepted into this LEC-PERC program, and am delighted to be learning about fascinating topics from great faculty, alongside my wonderful environmental law professor colleagues, in the midst of the stunning natural beauty of Big Sky's mountains, valleys, forests, rivers, and nighttime skies.