Monday, February 18, 2013

Sin Decir Aqua Va

As memes go, Marco Rubio's Poland Springs eternal.  Was this Rubio's Howard Dean moment?  Naturally, these things do happen in high slakes politics.  Senator Rubio was only testing the water by giving the Republican response to President Obama's 2013 State of the Union address.  Now, however, his reach for a tiny plastic bottle has gotten him in hot water, while, ironically, pouring cold water on his presidential candidacy.  He has tried to treat the incident as water off a duck's back, get his political head back above water, and forget about his aquatic lurch to the left as so much water under the bridge.  Meanwhile, the tide rises for another future contender for Republican greatness.  Even though he is more nominally suited for aquatics than Rubio, he prefers Tea Parties to bottled water, and spent his early youth in landlocked Alberta:  Senator Ted Cruz.

Wednesday, February 13, 2013

All The Products Fit To Print

In his February 12, 2012, State of the Union address, President Barack Obama highlit a technology with huge implications for manufacturing:
There are things we can do, right now, to accelerate this trend [towards more manufacturing in the United States]. Last year, we created our first manufacturing innovation institute in Youngstown, Ohio. A once-shuttered warehouse is now a state-of-the art lab where new workers are mastering the 3D printing that has the potential to revolutionize the way we make almost everything.
What he did not mention was that 3D printing may also democratize manufacturing, allowing individuals to make, repair, or modify products at home for the mere price of raw materials and electricity.  In addition, this technology is destined to challenge intellectual property law by facilitating inexpensive and high-fidelity copies of goods protected by patent, copyright, or trademark.  Can it be long before a Digital Millennium Copyright Act-like legal response materializes?

Thursday, February 7, 2013

Nothing Under The Sun That Is Made Of Man

As part of the SCOTUSblog symposium on the AMP v. Myriad case currently before the United States Supreme Court, my short symposium article, "Nothing Under The Sun That Is Made Of Man," was published on February 7, 2013.  To summarize, I argue that the Supremes will answer "No" to their question, "Should human genes be patentable?," and will be motivated by a longterm trend prohibiting the patenting of human beings.  I plan to publish a full article about this issue soon after the Supremes decide the case this term.

Wednesday, February 6, 2013

Patently Negative

Two Washington University Professors Michele Boldrin and David Levine, who are also Research Fellows at the Federal Reserve Bank of Saint Louis, have published their latest critique of the patent system.  Their lead article in the Journal of Economic Perspectives (Volume 27, Number 1, Winter 2013, pages 3-22) is entitled "The Case Against Patents."  Here is an excerpt summarizing their argument:
The case against patents can be summarized briefly:  there is no empirical evidence that they serve to increase innovation and productivity, unless productivity is identifified with the number of patents awarded—which, as evidence shows, has no correlation with measured productivity.  This disconnect is at the root of what is called the “patent puzzle”: in spite of the enormous increase in the number of patents and in the strength of their legal protection, the US economy has seen neither a dramatic acceleration in the rate of technological progress nor a major increase in the levels of research and development expenditure.
Both theory and evidence suggest that while patents can have a partial equilibrium effect of improving incentives to invent, the general equilibrium effect on innovation can be negative.  The historical and international evidence suggests that while weak patent systems may mildly increase innovation with limited side effects, strong patent systems retard innovation with many negative side effects.  More generally, the initial eruption of innovations leading to the creation of a new industry—from chemicals to cars, from radio and television to personal computers and investment banking—is seldom, if ever, born out of patent protection and is instead the fruit of a competitive environment.
In their 2008 book, "Against Intellectual Monopoly," Boldrin and Levine argued that both patents and copyrights impose substantial negative effects on society, although trademarks might be more benign.

Professor Bill Tomlinson and I have also studied the patent system using a participatory computer simulation system called The Patent Game.  We have published our experimental results thus far in three articles:  (1) Patents and the Regress of Useful Arts, (2) Patent Expertise and the Regress of Useful Arts, and (3) Property Rules, Liability Rules, and Patent Law:  One Experimental View from the Cathedral.  In 2010, I was invited to present our results in a Google TechTalk at Google headquarters in Mountain View, California.

Abraham Lincoln might disagree with "The Case Against Patents."  His view of the patent system was positively sublime:
In the world's history certain inventions and discoveries occurred of peculiar value, on account of their great efficiency in facilitating all other inventions and discoveries. Of these were the art of writing and of printing, the discovery of America, and the introduction of patent laws. [Emphasis added]
It is nothing short of remarkable, in 2013, we still appear to know very little about the costs and benefits of patents, a system of incentives that has been in use to encourage innovation for more than 500 years - and whose use has been increasing rapidly all around the world.

Tuesday, February 5, 2013

Wolverine Woes

That famous mustelidophile, W.C. Fields, once complained that "Some weasel took the cork out of my lunch."  Lovers of liquid lunches need lie awake no longer, for the largest of the weasels - the wolverine (Gulo gulo) - may be headed into oblivion in the lower 48 United States.  So dire is the plight of the "glutton" that the United States Fish and Wildlife Service proposed, on February 1, 2013, to list the wolverine as "Threatened" under the Endangered Species Act.  Without effective conservation measures, the wolverine may become an ex species known only as one of the X-Men.

Monday, February 4, 2013

SCOTUSblog On Human Gene Patents

This week, SCOTUSblog will feature an online symposium to discuss the AMP v. Myriad Genetics case currently before the United States Supreme Court.  The Supremes are considering the following question:  "Are human genes patentable?"  I and several of my colleagues have been asked to participate.  Feel free to follow the discussion on SCOTUSblog.  I will also provide updates here.  This should be a lot of fun, and, perhaps, even a tad important.

Tuesday, January 29, 2013

Worry-Wort

In addition to its uses in folk medicine (e.g., to treat depression), Saint John's Wort (Hypericum perforatum) has long been hung in houses to ward off evil spirits.  Now, this plant itself is being portrayed as bad, at least for one's health.  Pharmacists Planning Service, Inc. has filed a petition with the U.S. Food and Drug Administration ("FDA") to switch the Wort's regulated status "from herbal Dietary Supplement to behind pharmacy counter status (BPCS)."  This pharmacists' group suggest that Saint John's Wort "can cause trouble sleeping, vivid dreams, restlessness, anxiety, irritability, stomach upset, fatigue, dry mouth, dizziness, headache, skin rash, diarrhea, and tingling."  Inconveniently, from the perspective of mnemonics alone, what this plant apparently fails to cause is warts.

Monday, January 28, 2013

An Achilles Heel Of Climate Change

January 28th in the U.S. Midwest is cold.  The ground is often covered in snow.  Birds huddle for warmth against the wintry wind.  People wrap themselves in thick clothes and boots, comforting themselves that spring will arrive less than two months hence.

However, January 28, 2013, in the Midwest was warm.  The sun shone.  The birds sang spring songs.  Trees almost looked as if they were going to bud.  People wore shorts, t-shirts, and running shoes.  Almost everyone enjoyed the weird warm weather.

Frequent storms, droughts, and ferocious forest fires may be harbingers of even greater global climate change to come.  These events frighten people, and spur them to condemn the causes of climate change.  On the other hand, beautiful summer days in January make climate change seem benign - even desirable.  Opponents of climate change might have difficulty getting others to agree with them on a day as clement as today.  This could be a serious barrier to achieving political action on climate change.  Perhaps people will contemplate this conundrum as they picnic on the grass.

Friday, January 25, 2013

Dulce Et Decorum Est Pro Industria Mori

Kevin Noonan, an exceptionally talented biotechnology patent attorney, has written a fascinating article on Patent Docs, the premier biotechnology patent blog, suggesting that Myriad Genetics might fall on its sword to save the rest of its industry from a damaging Supreme Court opinion.  Here is his conclusion:
[T]he question must be asked whether the prudent thing for Myriad to do is grant Dr. Ostrer a covenant not to sue on all the patents and claims involved in this litigation.  The result would be to render the issues before the Court moot;  regardless of the perceived importance of the Question Presented, even the Supreme Court is limited by Article III of the Constitution and cannot render an advisory opinion on this issue.  Such an action by Myriad would not only prevent this case from being decided, it would preclude the Court from including in its opinion dicta on the patent eligibility of isolated DNA from other species (which may have importance in fields like agriculture or biofuels) or other "products of nature" that may provide the basis for biologic and other types of drugs.  In view of the seemingly complete lack of any practical reason for having the Supreme Court decide this issue, and the risks to the progress provided for a generation by the biotechnology industry, nothing other than a desire to be vindicated remains to support seeing this case through to its conclusion.  Frankly, in view of what is at stake, such vindication is simply not enough.
As usual, Noonan has thought well ahead of the crowd.  Myriad is unlikely to take his advice, but it and its industry may regret the result.

Thursday, January 24, 2013

Prize Pythons

The Burmese Python (Python molurus bivittatus) are gigantic snakes native to Asia, ranging from Pakistan to China to Indonesia.  Probably released into the wild by pet owners in Florida, Burmese Pythons have become important invasives of the Everglades, where their viable breeding populations are exploding.  Capable of reaching 6 meters in length, in their adoptive Florida these snakes have been know to capture and ingest even prey as large the American Alligator (Alligator mississippiensis) and White-Tailed Deer (Odocoileus virginianus).  Government programs to eradicate the invasive Python have failed thus far.  So, as reported in the New York Times on January 24, 2013, the Wildlife Foundation of Florida is sponsoring the 2013 Python Challenge, which offers training for aspiring participants, as well as two $1,500 Grand Prizes for the most Pythons captured, and two $1,000 prizes for the longest Pythons captured.  The Challenge runs from January 12 to February 10, 2013.  However, the Everglades cover a vast area, and Burmese Pythons have proven to be prodigiously-fertile invasives.  Consider one lesson from that font of wisdom, Escape from New York:
Brain:  I swear to God, Snake, I thought you were dead.
Snake Plissken:  Yeah.  You and everybody else.
Like Snake Plisskin, Burmese Pythons may be impossible to manage, let alone to eradicate.